The Record of Woodland Park reports that Thursday's ruling also confirms the murder conviction of Edward Ates, a Florida man who was sentenced to life in prison after failing to persuade a jury of the argument that he was too fat to have committed the 2006 murder of his son-in-law.
Ates' attorney, Walter Lesnevich, tells the newspaper he plans to appeal Thursday's ruling to the state Supreme Court.
Ates was convicted in 2009 of fatally shooting his former son-in-law. An investigation by Bergen County prosecutors included wiretapping calls Ates made from Florida to his mother and sister in Louisiana.
Get Eyewitness News Delivered