Authorities say the man vanished in the waters off Sayreville at about 8 p.m. Monday.
Two men were out fishing near Morgan Marina when their boat lost its motor. One of them jumped to find it, but he never resurfaced.
Divers worked through they night to try and find the man, but were unsuccessful.
Police are expected to release more information, and possibly the man's identity, on Tuesday.
Get Eyewitness News Delivered