Police say the man was found in the crosswalk on Columbus Avenue at 104th Street on the Upper West Side about 10:30 Saturday night.
The pizza, delivery bag and a shoe were left on the pavement.
One witness described a chaotic scene where the man was hit first by one car, and then another.
""It was crazy", said Michael Martinez. "It was just a bang and I turned around and I see him in the air flying. Then he just hit the car. It was over."
Police say the driver of the gray two-door vehicle that hit the man stayed on the scene.
Get Eyewitness News Delivered