"It's bewildering," said Craig Peters, 21-year-old Finnegan Elder's family attorney. " They gave him and they gave Gabe a sentence that is befitting a mafia boss who wantonly kills innocent people. How could these boys possibly be in that same league?"
WATCH FULL DOCUMENTARY:32 Seconds: A Deadly Night in Rome'
Elder and his friend, 20-year-old Gabriel Natale Hjorth, both from the Bay Area, received Italy's harshest sentence for their crimes.
On a July night in Rome, back in 2019, they were on a street corner to meet someone associated with a drug dealer. But, two police officers in plain clothes approached. In a struggle, Officer Mario Cerciello Rega pinned Elder to the ground; the young man stabbed the officer to death.
An appeal of the verdict is in the works, and the Elder family's attorney points out how different the process is in Italy.
"In America, the end of that first trial is, most of the time, the end of the road. But in Italy, it's very different. So we're trying to remind him that there is a whole other trial, essentially, that's going to happen at the appellate level, where hopefully we will have more sophisticated, more experienced, more reasonable and rational judges who will actually do the hard work of trying to make sense of all this and then fairly apportion justice," Peters said.
The deadly altercation lasted just 32 seconds in July 2019. On Wednesday afternoon in a courtroom in Rome, the two college students received life in prison.
The verdict came after 11 p.m. Rome time; it took the panel just a day to decide. A long ordeal is over for the victim's widow, but the defendants' lawyers and their parents pledge to appeal.
Twenty-one-year-old Finnegan Elder of San Francisco learned to speak Italian during his 22 months in a Rome prison. And you could see it on his face as he realized the verdict - guilty of the murder of Deputy Brigadier Mario Cerciello Rega - and his sentence, life in prison.
Officer Cerciello Rega's widow, who had just married the officer the month before his death, burst into tears, hugging her lawyers and her husband's partner, who was there during the deadly altercation.
Twenty-year-old Gabriel Natale Hjorth of Marin County received the same sentence; he struggled with Rega's partner, Andrea Varriale, that night.
In newly-released video, Varriale insisted he and Cerciello Rega identified themselves as police as they approached the Americans at 3 in the morning.
Elder and Natale-Hjorth thought they were meeting a drug dealer's contact, so they could return the backpack they stole after a drug deal went bad.
But Elder insisted neither officer identified themselves that night; they were in plain clothes with no weapons, badges or handcuffs.
Elder testified on March 1, "In the blink of an eye, they turned around and rushed us without saying a single word."
Cerciello Rega pinned Elder to the ground, and the young man stabbed the officer 11 times with a combat-style knife.
Elder told the court on March 1, "I'm truly sorry and deeply saddened for the loss of Mr. Cerciello."
Leah Elder, Finn's mother, texted the ABC7 I-Team Wednesday afternoon that she is "stunned, heartbroken, angry." While the appeals move forward, Mrs. Elder told us, "I'm gonna focus on Finn's survival right now. It's my only concern."
The I-Team's Dan Noyes received a statement from the Natale-Hjorth's parents Thursday:
"Our family is astounded that Gabriel was convicted, without a shred of evidence against him, of a crime he did not commit. We can only hope that the appeals court will make its decision based on the facts, as opposed to the prosecution's unfounded arguments, and therefore recognize Gabriel's innocence."
Elder's attorney Craig Peters also released a statement:
On the record: I am confounded by this verdict that lacks both reason and compassion. It lays all the blame with two young boys, while holding blameless the Carabinieri who failed to follow basic police procedures which, had they been followed, would have Cerciello Rega with us here today. This verdict makes a mockery of justice by believing an incoherent story professed by an admitted liar, and then compensating that liar with an award of 50,000, while subjecting these boys to a sentence that is reserved for unredeemable, career criminals that commit premeditated killings.
The message sent by these judges is loud and clear. Those in a position of power, the Carabinieri and the prosecutors, can lie and mislead and they will not be held responsible. Those accused can tell the truth and acknowledge their own part in wrongdoing, and they will not receive credit for doing so. This is a sad day for holding those in positions of power accountable. This is a sad day for justice. I look forward to having the appellate court, with experienced, rational judges, objectively review the facts to determine a just outcome in this case for these two young boys.