Cary officials said the three men were arrested at a Red Roof Inn just before 2 a.m. after Ohio authorities alerted the Cary Police Department that the inmates would be in the area.
Troy McDaniel Jr., Brynn Martin and Christopher Clemente were the three men taken into custody without incident.
The fourth suspect, Lawrence Lee III, was captured later on in the day in Durham.
"I would like to thank the hard working law enforcement professionals who have tirelessly dedicated themselves to providing an end to the search for these escapees," Gallia County Sheriff Matt Champlin said in a statement. "Additionally, I want to thank everyone who has shown support for my office and our law enforcement across this great nation. Everyday, our jobs become tougher and more dangerous. My staff and I appreciate your continued prayers and support as we continue to work hard for you every day."
Police K-9 dogs initially tried to track Lee's scent, but were unsuccessful.
Ohio officials said the four men were previously behind bars at a county jail in Gallipolis, Ohio. On Sunday, authorities say they overpowered two female corrections officers using a shank and escaped by stealing the keys to a police vehicle. A shank is commonly referred to as a makeshift knife.
They reportedly drove that police vehicle a few blocks before ditching it in favor of a car that was waiting for them.
Champlin said someone on the outside left that car for the inmates to use to make their getaway.
The men were awaiting extradition to Ohio.
Court records show the men were behind bars on charges of domestic violence, assault, menacing, drug possession, burglary and unlawful restraint.
* Follow us on YouTube
* More local news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts