Authorities said six thieves broke into a locked case of liquor at Total Wine & More just off Route 4 in River Edge last Friday evening.
The suspects used shopping carts to block an aisle while they broke into the case and removed bottles of 1952 Tullibardine, Highland Park (50 years old) and Macallan V5 Reflexion valued at nearly $52,000.
They also took a $68 bottle of Pinch Scotch.
Surveillance cameras captured images of the suspects, who remain at large.
Anyone with information is asked to call River Edge Police at 201-262-1233.