Panel recommends eliminating gifted programs at New York City schools

WABC logo
Wednesday, August 28, 2019
Panel recommends eliminating gifted programs at New York City schools
EMBED <>More Videos

Dave Evans has the latest on the recommendation to eliminate gifted programs at NYC schools.

NEW YORK CITY (WABC) -- A diversity panel appointed by New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio spoke out Tuesday after recommending that the city eliminate its gifted programs at schools.

In a report from the panel, they claim the popular programs promote racial and economic divisions.

Instead, they propose replacing gifted programs with non-selective "magnet schools" open to students with varying academic abilities to encourage diversity.

The panel appointed by the mayor said there is something terribly wrong when 70 percent of the school system is black and Latino -- yet gifted and talented programs are mostly white and Asian.

"A culture that thinks that if you call something gifted and talented, it means your kid is better, that's what we're trying to move away from," Diversity Group Chair Maya Wiley said.

The panel made the following recommendations:

-A moratorium scrapping all gifted and talented programs

-Eliminate a single high-stakes test for admission

-Add new academic programs for bright students

Schools Chancellor Richard Carranza weighed in on what could become a minefield, balancing integration and academic excellence.

"This is now about lowering the bar, it's about giving all of our students what they need to meet the bar that we set," Carranza said.

The changes could weigh heavily on the mayor's presidential aspirations and he was careful on Tuesday to remain vague on the diversity panel's recommendations.

"How do you strike that balance? We want kids to learn to learn together in diversity, we want to break down barriers, we also want to make sure we have academic strength," De Blasio said.

The mayor risks alienating white, Asian and well-to-do parents. They could simply flee to the suburbs.

Panel members called that fear of integration unfounded.

"But the thought that someone else's children and their families are innately dangerous to your success or your well-being is something that harms every single person," student Leanne Nunes said.

City Council Speaker Corey Johnson said he is against the proposal.

"Desegregation must be a priority, and I look forward to reviewing this report in full," he said in a statement. "But while I support moving away from relying on a single test for admissions to elite schools, I don't believe eliminating gifted and talented programs outright is the solution. We need to revamp admissions to gifted programs on the district level so that they reflect the diversity of our city's students. But we must be thoughtful about the process and make sure all stakeholders can weigh in."

The changes in gifted and talented programs would not affect the city's eight elite high schools like Stuyvesant. Changes could be phased in over the next three to five years.

CLICK HERE to read the full report.


* More New York City news

* Send us a news tip

* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts

* Follow us on YouTube