The damage to the church is significant, but congregants say their spirit is still alive, and they are thankful.
"Upstairs is fairly burnt up, the chairs are destroyed, and water damage everywhere. The rafters are burned as well," said Pastor Remo Madsen.
ALSO READ | Christmas unites community after fire guts historic church
Pastor Madsen held a small in-person service on Christmas Eve - all was sound when the last person left around 8 p.m., and then on Christmas Morning, the 70-year-old church on Hempstead Turnpike was seen up in flames.
"The smoke was shooting out of the roof of the building," said Church Music Director Gail George.
It is a close-knit church family that Fritzie Pisarski has been a part of for 15 years.
"This is devastating that I no longer have a home church," said Pisarski.
While the damage inside is significant, the pastor says the building is not a total loss.
"One of the glass windows with children sitting on Jesus' knee is a favorite, and that was saved. That was important to many people," said Pastor Madsen.
There were no in-person services on Christmas Day due to the pandemic, and parishioners say while their beloved building is in shambles, and it is hard to look at, the fire did not break their holiday spirit.
"This is a building. It's a church - but we as the people - we are the church," said Special Events Coordinator Wendy Lantigua.
The church says they are going to build back stronger and better.
ALSO READ | Worshippers limited at St. Patrick's Cathedral midnight mass
* More Long Island news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts
* Follow us on YouTube
Submit a News Tip