Archdiocese lets girls back on boys' hoops team after threats to forfeit

CLARK, N.J. -- Two girls have been cleared to rejoin a boys' Catholic youth basketball squad in New Jersey after church officials reversed an earlier decision that the fifth-grade team could not be coed.

Archdiocese of Newark Cardinal Joseph Tobin announced the change Wednesday.

The boys on the St. John's team in Clark had decided to give up their season rather than play a game without their female teammates. The rest of their season was then forfeited.

The archdiocese had said that Catholic Youth Organization rules state that teams should be boys or girls only. However, found that the league rules do not mention whether the teams in St. John's division -- the JV black league -- can or cannot be coed.

Archdiocese spokesman Jim Goodness said Tobin believes the team shouldn't have been penalized for mistakes that adults responsible for following league rules might have made.

According to Goodness, Tobin asked CYO officials to "study the current league rules regarding participation and team makeup in all age groups" and reinstated the team's 7-3 record.

Rob Martel, coach and father of one of the girls, fought back tears when he told the team that its season was going to continue and they would be going to the playoffs.

"This is all we ever wanted," assistant coach Keisha Martel said. "This was never about being defiant or wanting to break, bend or change rules. It was about fairness for these 10-year-olds, about finishing the season the way they started -- together."

Tobin said he wanted the children to play for the reasons CYO sports were established. "To provide a source of both recreation and reaffirmation of our Christian faith," Tobin said.

Related Video
Views from the 6: Learning sportsmanship from N.J. fifth-graders
Views from the 6: Learning sportsmanship from N.J. fifth-graders
Michael Smith says there is a lot we can learn from the fifth-grade team at St. John the Apostle School in New Jersey, whose players decided not to compete if they couldn't play without their female players.
Copyright © 2022 ESPN Internet Ventures. All rights reserved.