The elusive cat was reportedly spotted in Rochester on Wednesday sauntering down a street.
Police say social media video appears to show what is likely a mountain lion, and they also received multiple calls of reported sightings.
A shelter-in-place was ordered but was later lifted when police couldn't verify the lurking lion.
Still, neighbors said they are feeling nervous.
"I just saw something big walking just right over there, right over there, it went right over there, I swear ,I promise you, it went right over there," Curtis Jones told the ABC affiliate in Rochester. "And it said 'rawr' and I just kept walking...I seen it, seeing me, see it. So, in my head I'm like, 'nah I got to go man, I'm out.'"
For now, the big cat saga is still a mystery.
Meanwhile, the Seneca Park Zoo confirmed all of its animals are accounted for.
The New York Department of Environmental Conservation released a statement that said it is also investigating reports of the big cat in Rochester.
The DEC reminded the public to treat any encounter with a potentially dangerous animal the same -- by keeping a safe distance and slowly back away. They say to only take photos from a safe distance and immediately report it to law enforcement.
----------
* Get Eyewitness News Delivered
* Follow us on YouTube
* More local news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts