The Middle Church congregation marched from their temporary home at Calvary Episcopal Church on 21st Street and Park Avenue South to the ruins of their sanctuary at 7th Street and Second Avenue in the East Village.
The ceremony kicked off with a sermon at Calvary by Rev. Dr. Jacqui Lewis, followed by a procession through the streets with freedom songs and Christmas carols.
"If we don't sit in our grief and don't acknowledge our pain, it's not as easy to heal," Lewis said.
Once they reached the sanctuary, Rev. Lewis finished her sermon and the congregation celebrated with communion.
"Look at everyone, they are happy to see one another and isn't that what church and community is about," worshipper Dorie Hagler said.
The six-alarm blaze that gutted the church on December 5, 2020, was built in 1892.
The fire started next door at a vacant building where electrical work was being done.
Raging fire in East Village damages historic church; 4 firefighters suffer minor injuries
The site had been linked to several key events in American history.
In early October, services resumed with an outdoor celebration in the shadows of what was left of the building.
Historic church gutted by fire holds 1st in-person worship since COVID
As for rebuilding ... that's a challenge. Rev. Lewis tells Eyewitness News the person who wins the land where the fire started, will not allow crews to access the lot where the church once stood.
The only way in is through the facade, and it's not sitting well with many members of this congregation.
"This was really shoddy workmanship being done that night and caused the loss of a true, irreplaceable treasure," worshipper Anthony Donovan said.
By the end of the year, they'll find out whether this can once again be home base. If not, they're committed to staying in this community.
----------
* Get Eyewitness News Delivered
* More Manhattan news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts
* Follow us on YouTube
Submit a News Tip