Pictures of the vandalized flag were obtained by Eyewitness News after the owner of the service center, Joe Kurek, made the discovery.
This is the second incident to occur at the same business recently.
They blame fellow Jews in Monsey who belong to an ultra-orthodox Jewish sect.
They base that claim on the numerous people who each day come in to their long-time service center and ask them to take down the flag.
Video in player above from previous report.
On May 17, surveillance cameras caught someone ripping down the Israeli flag in front of the center.
Kurek said the stolen flag was a gift from a dear friend who died last year a friend who served in the military and brought the flag from Israel to Monsey.
The new flag was put up last week.
MORE NEWS: NJ man accused of attacking mechanic with bleach at service station
NJ man accused of attacking mechanic with bleach at service station
* Get Eyewitness News Delivered
* Follow us on YouTube
* More local news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts