The union representing LIRR workers is pushing for higher pay, but MTA leaders warn that agreeing to those demands could trigger significant fare hikes.
The MTA says if a strike happens, it will roll out a contingency plan that includes shuttle buses to help move riders.
Five unions representing 3,500 workers, including engineers, signalmen and trainmen, are threatening to strike on May 16.
The unions and LIRR have agreed to a retroactive 9.5% wage increase covering the last three years. But, the sticking point remains an additional 5% raise the workers want beginning this year.
The MTA says that's too high. The MTA has also pushed back about some of the lucrative penalty pay workers receive when tasked with certain jobs during a shift.
MTA officials say if they give LIRR workers what they are asking for, it could result in a fare hike as high as 8%.
More than a quarter million people ride the LIRR each day, and if there is a strike, the MTA would run free shuttle bus service from a limited number of LIRR stations: Lakeview, Hicksville, Ronkonkoma, Mineola, and Huntington bringing riders to a subway station.
For riders, the first strike in decades would be daunting, but most say they'd navigate through it.
White House-appointed mediators say there is no indication the MTA cannot afford the proposed increases.
Union members have announced plans for a rally in Massapequa this weekend.
"While the MTA boasts about expanding service revenue, our unions fall farther behind," said union leader Gillman Lang. "We have made compromises in our ask and are ready to sit down at the bargaining table and settle an agreement now."
----------
* Get Eyewitness News Delivered
* Download our connected TV app
* More local news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts on the go