Those who planned ahead and were willing to spend about $98 for a round-trip ticket generally found New Jersey Transit to be a reliable option. Governor Mikie Sherrill, who rode the train to the match, said it was the simplest way in.
"This is the easiest way to commute," she said.
Not everyone agreed on the value. "It's easy, but it's expensive," said Brazil supporter Paulo Vita.
Some fans arrived at Newark Penn Station well before kickoff and had time to spare. Many made their way to Newark's Ironbound neighborhood, known for its strong Brazilian presence, to grab food, socialize, and get into the spirit of the match.
Predictions for the game varied, with some fans expecting a decisive Brazil victory and others calling for a tighter contest.
"Three-zero Brazil."
"Four-zero Brazil."
"One-one... a little humble," fans said, laughing as they shared their picks.
Visitors were also surprised to find the region focused on another major sporting event at the same time, as excitement around the New York Knicks competed with World Cup buzz.
"Today Knicks end it all, and Knicks will join the fun," Vita joked.
For many, the experience itself was worth the cost. David Vega, a Costa Rican fan whose team did not qualify, chose to support Brazil, and had the tickets to prove it.
"I think Brazil wins 2-0," he said. "A lot of money, yeah, but just one game, one World Cup game is good for me."
Ali Memar, who has tickets to several matches but missed this one due to a business trip, said Brazil has been his team since childhood.
"Brazil was my team since I was six years old. Pelé was playing," he said.
Fans who chose to drive faced heavy traffic, with many directed to park at the American Dream Mall. Some found themselves stuck in gridlock before even reaching the stadium, relieved to finally get out of their cars once they arrived.
State officials said rail service was the most heavily used form of transportation, with fans boarding trains in New York, Newark, and Secaucus.
"Everybody was feeling very good about the experience," Governor Sherrill said.
At the stadium, yellow Brazil jerseys dominated the crowd, though Moroccan fans were also visible throughout. Despite the large turnout, trains were not completely full, suggesting many local Brazil fans opted to drive.
That choice came at a steep price: parking near the stadium cost up to $225.
----------
* Get Eyewitness News Delivered
* More New York City news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts
* Download our connected TV app