9-year-old called overweight after school fitness test

NEW YORK (WABC) --
Gwendolyn Williams is an energetic 9-year-old.She is 4'1" and weighs 66 pounds, but based on the Fitnessgram report she just got at school, she is overweight.

"I was like 66 pounds - overweight? That doesn't make any sense," says Gwendolyn.

Gwendolyn's mother, Laura says she was very angry.

"My daughter isn't overweight - by whatever index they're measuring it might have put her in that category," Laura said.

BMI, or Body Mass Index is calculated based on height and weight. Critics argue that it is not always a great measure of heath because it does not take into account muscle mass, bone density and overall body composition.

Over 870,000 students of all ages take home a New York City Fitnessgram every year. As a psychologist at the Child Mind institute, Dr. Rachel Busman worries that without an explanation, the information may impact self-image.

"For kids who are overweight and know they're overweight, they will get this letter and feel worse," said Dr. Busman.

It is not clear if Gwen's BMI is accurate, but her mother says regardless, Fitnessgram should not be sent home with students.

"I'm hoping the DOE listens and all they have to do is mail it home to the parents," said Laura.

In response, the New York City Department of Education says Fitnessgram notices are a longstanding tool that help families stay aware of weight and fitness as one part of an overall approach to ensuring their child's heath.

When it comes to why these Fitnessgrams are sent home with students and not with parents, the Department of Education did not comment directly but says they are open to exploring other options.

They do point out that the Fitnessgrams are used nationally, not just in New York City.

For more information on New York City Fitnessgrams, go to: http://schools.nyc.gov/Academics/FitnessandHealth/NycFitnessgram/NYCFITNESSGRAM.htm