Members gathered outdoors on a lawn adjacent to Grace Presbyterian Church.
The 132-year-old church caught fire on Tuesday. The roof collapsed and there was extensive damage.
No one was inside the church at the time of the fire.
"I was married here 54 years... still attend the church," said Ray Carnevale.
"My children were baptized there," said Antonio Argibay. "It's painful, very painful."
"This was my family of faith," said Julie Daidone.
The parishioners are far from alone -- several Presbyterian ministers in the area are offering support and whatever other help the congregation needs.
ALSO READ | Exclusive NYPD ride along exposes illicit sex trade in NYC
Exclusive look at NYPD's strategy to combat sex trafficking in NYC
ALSO READ | Mom grieving after kids, husband killed in crash on way to get ice cream in Massapequa
Mom grieving after kids, husband killed on way to get ice cream
----------
* Get Eyewitness News Delivered
* More New Jersey news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts
* Follow us on YouTube