The only lead: an old black-and-white snapshot found on the body that showed a grandfatherly man holding a small boy in the crook of his arm, both in attire of the 1950s or early 1960s.
Police assumed the toddler was the drowning victim, but years of investigation brought only dead ends and fizzled leads. But this month, a few remarkable coincidences have given Andrew Bookless his name back.
Bookless was identified through dental records - but only after police seeking to identify the little boy wrongly guessed a vintage light fixture in the picture may have been in western Massachusetts.
When they circulated the photo in the Berkshires, retired teacher Terry Yacubich, who had moved to Pittsfield from Bellport, N.Y., recognized a building behind the man and child as the same one she'd known in that small Long Island village.
Bookless' family, it turned out, once lived in the very spot the picture was taken.
"I'm not psychic or anything like that, but I think maybe Andrew worked through me to finally get some closure," Yacubich said.
Bookless left few clues about his identity after living a transient life marked by bouts of depression. He disappeared from his family's lives years before that June day when police found him dead at 31. The snapshot was intact in a glass frame and close to his heart under his layers of winter clothing.
Troopers searched for years to find someone who recognized the older man or features in the snapshot's background.
Investigator Joe Fiebich sent the picture this month to The Berkshire Eagle newspaper after learning the vintage street light in the background was similar to those installed throughout western Massachusetts decades ago.
It turned out they were common on Long Island's south shore, too.
But it wasn't the light fixture that grabbed Yacubich's attention when she slid her newspaper from its plastic sleeve on Saturday. She immediately recognized the church auditorium in the Long Island village where she'd lived for 47 years.
"The moment I saw that picture, I knew exactly where it was," said Yacubich, 59, who had attended decades' worth of first communion parties, church socials and funerals in the large auditorium at Mary Immaculate Roman Catholic Church.
Yacubich contacted longtime friend Donald Mullins, a retired Suffolk County, N.Y., police detective and code enforcement officer in Bellport, a village in the town of Brookhaven. He trekked to the church's neighborhood in the pouring rain and quickly found the spot: the front corner of a now-empty residential lot.
"I stood on that very spot and said, 'This is it. This is exactly it,"' Mullins said.
He tracked the land's ownership history in town deeds until he found that the Bookless family once had a house there before it was destroyed in a fire.
The Westchester County, N.Y., medical examiner's office confirmed Bookless' identity Jan. 25, and it was released this week after his four older siblings were notified.
They told police the man in the picture was Bookless' grandfather and that his parents, John and Marianna Bookless, had died in 1994 and 2004, respectively. Police said Bookless' family also had him declared dead after his mother's death.
Fiebich traveled Thursday to Long Island to talk with Bookless' family in hopes of determining whether the death was accidental or suicide. Investigators believe Bookless fell through the ice in the winter of 1992-93, months before his body was found with the rock-laden pack strapped on his back.
New York State Police Senior Investigator Patrick Bosley, one of several troopers who reviewed the case over the years, tried unsuccessfully in the mid-1990s to have it featured on the "Unsolved Mysteries" television show.
"It was obvious to us all along that the picture was the best piece of information we had," Bosley said. "It was clear that evidently the older gentleman was someone very close to him - his father or grandfather, a favorite uncle, someone he cared a lot about."
Bookless' family said he often would disappear for months, part of the reason his mother did not report him missing to Suffolk County police until 1999 even though she had not heard from him in several years, police said.
Bookless had been a standout cross-country runner in high school and later went on to play guitar and sail frequently, police said. His family had owned a rustic Westchester County bungalow near the reservoir where his body was located, about an hour north of New York City.
Police said Bookless' body was buried in New York as an unidentified person after the autopsy, but that his siblings will be able to move it if they wish.
"For me, the best end of the story would be to see that Andrew rests in peace," Yacubich said.
