Motive sought after handyman shoots well-known worker at Bronx construction site

CITY ISLAND, Bronx (WABC) -- Investigators are still trying to figure out why a local handyman allegedly shot and killed a friendly construction worker nicknamed "the mayor of City Island."

The suspect, 66-year-old Geraldo Reyes, frequently biked around the victim's Bronx construction site and brought sandwiches to 52-year-old Lizbeth Mass.

But on Wednesday, after the two had a brief discussion, police say Reyes left, returned with a stolen .44 caliber Smith and Wesson, and shot Mass six times.

"As we can discern at this time, she is a friendly person," NYPD Chief of Detectives James Essig said. "We don't know what triggered him in that, but there was no relationship to those two..."He comes by on his bike frequently. She always has a friendly smile for him, talks to him."

ALSO READ | Eli Manning, NY Giants help posthumously grant NJ girl's Make-A-Wish
EMBED More News Videos

Eli Manning and the New York Giants teamed with Make-A-Wish New Jersey to posthumously honor the wish of a 2-year-old girl who recently died of brain cancer.


The victim's 58-year-old boyfriend, who was visiting her at lunchtime, got into his own vehicle and struck Reyes with his car. He then exited his vehicle, ran after the suspect, beat him up, and held him until police arrived.

The suspect was actually arrested by an alert IRS agent who happened to be nearby at the time of the shooting.

The boyfriend is not being charged at this time, but the investigation is active and ongoing.

Detectives said Thursday that the gun was owned by a retired NYPD officer and that Reyes stole it while doing work at his house.

When the owner saw the shooting story on the news, he checked on his gun and realized it was missing.

The NYPD will now investigate that, and the department also confiscated two other personal weapons from him as a routine part of the investigation.

TRENDING: Former 'Bachelor' Colton Underwood comes out as gay on 'GMA'
EMBED More News Videos

Former 'Bachelor' Colton Underwood speaks his truth and comes out as gay on "Good Morning America."


Area residents said Mass had been at the construction site for a couple of weeks and was known to be animated while holding a sign telling people to slow down.

"We've come to know her," said one man who didn't want to be identified. "She's here every day, she's waving flags, she's very animated, she has a very bubbly personality, even the people that go for their morning walks have come to know her."

The man told Eyewitness News that a colleague was nearby when the shooting happened.

"This guy used to bring her sandwiches every day," the man said. "Today, he brought bullets instead."

Reyes is being treated for minor injuries at the hospital, with charges pending.

----------
* More Bronx news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts
* Follow us on YouTube
Submit a News Tip
Copyright © 2021 WABC-TV. All Rights Reserved.