But as the old adage dictates, the show must go on.
The performer who has been playing the title role is the same person who wrote the music and lyrics for the show, and Sara Bareilles said the show has changed her life and helped her cope with all that has happened since she was last on stage.
"We went through a collective global trauma," she said. "I also deal with a lot of depression and anxiety. I have for many, many years, and that was spiking really intensely over the pandemic. So I think my body is still processing some of that grief."
ALSO READ | Oscar conversation begins at New York Film Festival with 'Power of the Dog' cast
It helped Bareilles to return to perform the songs she wrote for her first Broadway show.
"It will be the great love of my artistic life until the day I die," she said. "It's changed everything. My life falls into two categories very clearly, before and after 'Waitress.' Everything about my life changed because of this show, and that's the magic of it."
Long before she reached the top of the popular music charts, Bareilles dreamed of appearing on Broadway, and so did her friend Jennifer Nettles, who is taking over her role.
"I grew up loving it and being a part of community theater in my little, tiny hometown of Douglas, Georgia," she said.
Nettles became a top country star but always kept her eye on the original prize. In fact, she and Bareilles first bonded over their shared love of Broadway show tunes.
It happened after Bareilles was hired to open for Nettles' band Sugarland a decade ago. While on tour, the pair discovered their common interest during a conversation before a show.
ALSO READ | 'Bruce Springsteen Live' exhibit opens at the Grammy Museum
It took several years before Nettles was available to appear in "Waitress," but now, she's taking over from her pal later this month.
Nettles said she is looking forward to singing Bareilles' lyrics, which have only been made more meaningful after the pandemic.
"Those themes of hope, of transformation, of redemption, all of those things are going to hit us more profoundly," Nettles said.
* Get Eyewitness News Delivered
* More New York City news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts
* Follow us on YouTube
Submit a News Tip