Chapman's first pitch to Brosseau with two out in the ninth inning whizzed past Brosseau's head, and umpires met before issuing warnings to both benches amid a budding rivalry that's been dominated this season by Tampa Bay. The Rays are 7-2 against the Yankees and lead second-place New York by 3 games in the American League East.
Chapman struck out Brosseau to end it, and Brosseau began walking toward the visiting dugout before turning back to exchange words with someone on the Yankees. The dugouts and benches emptied and players gathered near home plate, but they mostly kept their distance before dispersing to their respective clubhouses, and umpires stepped in.
Yankees starter Masahiro Tanaka hit Joey Wendle with a pitch in the first inning, which Rays manager Kevin Cash said he believed was intentional, prompting a bit of a back-and-forth with Yankees manager Aaron Boone after the game.
"It's absolutely ridiculous," Cash said. "It was mishandled by the Yankees. Certainly the pitcher on the mound. It was mishandled by the umpires.
"Somebody has to be accountable. The last thing I'll say on it is I got a whole damn stable full of guys that throw 98 mph. Period."
Told of Cash's apparent threat, Boone said it was "a pretty scary comment. I don't think that's right at all. But I'm not going to get into it right now."
Teams have been warned not to leave the benches this season as part of the league's coronavirus protocols. Players on both sides seemed to be urging others to deescalate.
Chapman began the season on the COVID-19 injured list. He had been 0-for-1 in save chances this season.
DJ LeMahieu homered twice, and Gio Urshela hit a tiebreaking, three-run little league homer in the sixth inning as New York beat the Rays at Yankee Stadium for the first time this season.
Tanaka (1-1) pitched six innings of two-run ball in his longest outing of the season. Five days after getting pulled in the fifth inning after 66 pitches at Atlanta, he allowed two runs and three hits and struck out a season-high seven batters.
The Yankees mounted a rally off Ryan Thompson (1-2) in the sixth to snap a 2-2 tie. They took a 5-2 lead when Urshela hit a sinking liner to center field for a two-run double, then scored thanks to shoddy Rays defense.
Center fielder Kevin Kiermaier attempted to make a diving catch, but the ball went past him and to the warning track, allowing Luke Voit and Clint Frazier to score. Urshela took third on the relay throw and scored when shortstop Willy Adames overthrew catcher Michael Perez for an error.
Urshela slid headfirst, and his right hand touched the plate before Perez could apply the tag from Thompson's throw. The call stood after the Rays challenged.
Urshela's hit helped the Yankees win for the fourth time in five games following a seven-game losing streak that was their longest since June 2017.
Zack Britton pitched a hitless eighth in his return from a hamstring injury.
The Rays saw their six-game winning streak snapped and also lost for only the third time in their past 16 games.
Kiermaier hit a two-run homer in the fifth off Tanaka, reaching the second deck in right field on an 0-2 slider. Adames hit a solo shot in the seventh off Jonathan Loaisiga.
LeMahieu hit his 11th career leadoff homer two pitches in, sending an 0-1 changeup just over the left-field fence against Trevor Richards. He homered again with one out in the third, hitting a 1-1 fastball just over the right-field wall.
It was LeMahieu's fourth career multihomer game and 71st multihit game since the start of last season, the most in the AL.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Benches clear at end of Yankees-Rays
After Aroldis Chapman throws a pitch over Michael Brosseau's head, they stare each other down at the end of the game, tempers flare and the benches clear prior to Rays and Yankees exiting.