But officials say shootings in Yonkers are uncommon, and in fact, there's been just three so far this year and 21 in all of 2021.
Yonkers is now the third largest city in New York, surging ahead of Rochester, and police give credit to the Safe Streets Task Force -- of which Menton was a part.
He was critically injured during an illegal gun investigation in a neighborhood hot spot, an area where last year there were shootings, including one that injured a 6-year-old boy.
TOP NEWS | Handyman arrested in case of murdered Queens mother stabbed more than 55 times
The suspect, identified as 28-year-old Bryant Jackson, was shot and killed by an FBI agent who returned fire.
Still, crime in Yonkers is down 45% over the last 10 years, and Mayor Mike Spano credits a shift in department policy so that officers actively engage with the community.
"In Yonkers, this size, where it's big but yet small enough where you can reach out and touch all sides, it's had a real effect," he said.
Spano took office at time when the Justice Department was investigating the Yonkers Police Department for systemic use of excessive force.
In 2016, the city agreed to implement 150 changes recommended by the DOJ.
"There is no way that we could've changed and transformed the way we did without having an outside entity like the Department of Justice assist us on that," Police Commissioner John Mueller said.
Mueller took over in 2019 and implemented precision policing.
"You're focusing on the people that are the most violent and the most prolific," he said. "In every crime category, there's a small group. If you know who they are, and you focus on them, everyone else can be left alone."
Not only has crime dropped, but so too have the number of arrests and the number of complaints against officers.
"We recognize that mass incarceration didn't work," Mueller said. "Carpet bombing stop, question and frisk for people who didn't do anything wrong didn't work."
ALSO READ | Recreational marijuana sales begin in New Jersey
The Rev. Jim Bostic is a longtime community leader who says the department has undergone a complete metamorphosis.
"The police abuse was rampant in the city of Yonkers," he said. "The city has made a very concerted effort to become a more community friendly police department."
Mueller said the community focused approach has many benefits.
"The vast majority of the time, it's just simply solving people's problems," he said. "We have many more opportunities to make friends than we do to make enemies, and we have to really, really leverage that."
Mueller says improving community relations has been his greatest achievement, and upholding that standard will be the challenge for the next top cop as the commissioner is retiring next week.
* More Northern Suburbs news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts
* Follow us on YouTube
Submit a News Tip