NJ family demanding answers after loved one's casket found unearthed, open

Anthony Johnson Image
Friday, April 30, 2021
Family demanding answers after loved one's coffin found unearthed, open
A heartbroken family from New Jersey who recently said goodbye to a loved one is now grappling with even more emotional pain.

HILLSIDE, New Jersey (WABC) -- A heartbroken family from New Jersey who recently said goodbye to a loved one is now grappling with even more emotional pain.

Paula Smith died from COVID-19 at just 60 years old, and her family turned her final farewell into a celebration of life.

On April 21, they watched her casket lowered into the ground at Evergreen Cemetery in Hillside. But over the weekend, they found it unearthed -- and open.

ALSO READ | Search on for NJ porch pirate who stole man's cancer medication

A porch pirate was captured on camera stealing vital medication for a cancer patient in Jersey City, New Jersey.

The grief of losing a loved one is traumatic enough, but after seeing what they saw, the pain has turned to anger.

Now, they are demanding answers.

"We noticed that that was our grandmother's casket because we just buried her," granddaughter Zinahyi Smith said. "Same casket, same gravestones around, and it was open."

They're also not the only ones, as other families found out their buried relatives' graves have been disturbed.

The Smith family was told they needed to hire a lawyer to get answers.

"Somebody in our family's casket is wide open, dug up," Zinahyi Smith said. "We watched her go down. Why is her casket open? That's the real question. Why is her casket open, and where is my grandmother?"

The area is now covered with mounds of dirt, and it seems that many more coffins are nearby. The land was disturbed, and there are rat holes along with toppled tombstones.

Other families are asking what has happened to their loved ones.

"Everybody else's family was coming out, saying they're known for this," Zinahyi Smith said. "They're known for this, and this is very sad. Because we should be able to trust them with our family members."

Assemblyman Jamel Holley, who represents the district, wants to get to the bottom of this painful situation.

"This, to me, is criminal," he said. "I think that this is all about greed and money, and at the end of the day, people come here for a safe place of peace of their loved ones."

Holley would like to see the families get reimbursed and for the state to launch an investigation into Hillside Cemetery.

TOP NEWS | Lady Gaga dognappers arrested 2 months after incident that left dog walker shot, wounded, police say

The Los Angeles Police Department on Thursday confirmed that it has made arrests in connection with the February theft of Lady Gaga's French bulldogs in Hollywood.


* Get Eyewitness News Delivered

* More New Jersey news

* Send us a news tip

* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts

* Follow us on YouTube

Submit a News Tip