Eviction temporarily paused for 90-year-old man fighting to keep Brooklyn home after deed scam

ByEyewitness News WABC logo
Thursday, August 8, 2024
Eviction of 90-year-old Brooklyn man temporarily paused in home deed scam case
A 90-year-old homeowner of a Park Slope brownstone has had his eviction temporarily paused in a case involving a deed scam.

PARK SLOPE, Brooklyn (WABC) -- The eviction of a 90-year-old Brooklyn homeowner who says he's the victim of fraud has been temporarily paused.

For over half a century, Ray Cortez has lived in the Park Slope brownstone where he raised his three children and expected to spend his final days.

The 90-year-old is now fighting for the right stay in his home in court, after he says he's been threatened with imminent eviction because the deed to the house shows someone else as the owner.

The eviction is on hold until September 9 when all parties will reconvene to see where the appellate court motion stands.

Cortez bought the house in 1969 for $20,000, long before the million-dollar condos went up and the Barclays Center moved in. Now the house is valued at close to $3 million.

The scam Cortez fell victim to is complicated, but the complication itself is part of the scam.

Back in 2006, Cortez, seeking money for renovations, was convinced to sign over the deed to his house to a conman who had done jail time.

A deed was returned in Cortez's name, notarized by a crooked attorney, but never recorded.

The conman took out an almost $700,000 line of credit on the house and eventually, the bank sold it at foreclosure for $2 million.

The 90-year-old didn't find out about it until a decade later.

A banner with the words "Deed Theft Victim" hangs outside 90-year-old Ray Cortez's brownstone demanding justice in his home deed scam case.
A banner with the words "Deed Theft Victim" hangs outside 90-year-old Ray Cortez's brownstone demanding justice in his home deed scam case.

Cortez's attorney said this type of fraud is common in gentrifying areas.

"If you go into certain neighborhoods, mostly communities of color in Brooklyn, kind of from Prospect Heights over towards East New York and then southeast Queens, everybody on every block knows somebody who has been a victim of deed theft or real estate fraud," his lawyer Bill Lienhard said.

Cortez's son, Ray Jr., has been helping his father navigate the legal morass that he said is a result of a decades-old scam.

"You know, it's heartbreaking. It's been too long for him to have to carry this with him. It's been devastating," Ray Jr. said.

Now, neighbors who have known Cortez for almost 40 years are rallying behind him.

"The perfect neighbor. All of us on this street are just appalled. I mean we cannot imagine what this must be doing to him emotionally," said neighbor Tom Harriman.

The Attorney General's office has a division that looks into this type of real estate fraud and is reviewing Cortez's case.

ALSO READ | Couple leaving behind legacy of love and wisdom as Katinka in East Village set to close

Entertainment reporter Joelle Garguilo follows the journey of beloved mom and pop shop on East 9th Street as it prepares to close its doors.

----------

* Get Eyewitness News Delivered

* More Manhattan news

* Send us a news tip

* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts

* Follow us on YouTube

Submit a tip or story idea to Eyewitness News

Have a breaking news tip or an idea for a story we should cover? Send it to Eyewitness News using the form below. If attaching a video or photo, terms of use apply.