New York Boy Scouts hire gay Eagle Scout despite national policy

Darla Miles Image
Thursday, April 2, 2015
NY Boy Scouts hire openly gay Eagle Scout as camp leader
Darla Miles reports on the hiring that is a direct challenge to the national Boy Scout's organization ban on openly gay adult members.

NEW YORK -- The Boy Scouts' New York chapter said Thursday that it has hired the nation's first openly gay Eagle Scout as a summer camp leader, a direct and public challenge to the national scouting organization's ban on openly gay adult members.

The Boy Scouts' national spokesman, Deron Smith, said there was no change in that national policy, which has been highly divisive. As for any further response to the New York announcement, Smith said, "We are looking into this matter."

The challenge to the national headquarters was laid down by the Boy Scouts' Greater New York Councils, which announced the hiring of Pascal Tessier, an 18-year-old Eagle Scout. Tessier has been a vocal advocate of opening the 105-year-old organization to gay scouts and leaders.

"He's highly qualified for the job, and we accepted him for the job. Regardless of his sexual orientation," said Ricky Mason of the Greater New York Councils of Boy Scouts.

Tessier is a recently minted Eagle Scout from Maryland.

"For a very, very long time we've had an anti-discrimination policy, and that's anti-discrimination in every respect, including with regard to sexual orientation," said Mason.

Mason says New York didn't hesitate with bringing Tessier on board, even though it's against the organization's national policy. Two years ago, Boy Scouts of America made an about face, allowing openly gay members under the age of 18.

But openly gay adults above the age of 18 are still not allowed.

Tessier was an openly gay member of the Boy Scouts under the new, revised policy. But he turned 18 last August, and that's when everything changed.

"We've put his application in through the normal process, they have not rejected him yet," said Mason.

"The Boy Scouts policies for adult leaders and employees have not changed," says the organization in a written statement. "While we were only recently made aware of this issue, we are looking into the matter."

"He's an applicant for a job. And if they do make efforts to block him, he has his legal rights whatever they may be and he may decide to pursue them," said Mason.

A legal battle might be in store, with Scouts for Equality saying, "We're proud to be working with Pascal as he stands up for his rights as protected by law."

"He's an exemplary candidate and we made that decision based on merit," said Mason. "I don't think we would have said no. He made an application to us...he's highly qualified.

The national organization changed its policy in 2013 to allow openly gay youth as scouts, but not adults as leaders, after a bitter debate over its membership policy. The change took effect in January 2014.

Advocates for letting gays participate in scouting hailed Tessier's hire.

"This is a watershed moment," Zach Wahls, executive director of Scouts for Equality, said in a statement. "We are proud to see such an important Boy Scout council standing up for the full inclusion of gay members."

When the national Boy Scouts began allowing gay boys as scouts, liberal Scout leaders and gay rights groups celebrated the shift but called for allowing gay adults to participate, too. Conservatives involved with the Scouts, including some churches that sponsor troops, decried letting any gays - including kids - participate. Some defected when the ban on gay youth was lifted.

The Boy Scouts of America has said it doesn't "proactively inquire" about members' sexual orientation - in effect, a form of "don't ask, don't tell." But it has expelled adults who were open about it, including a gay troop leader in Seattle who was removed last year after he disclosed his orientation during a TV interview.

While some other local Boy Scout councils also have let it be known they are accepting of openly gay employees, the 103-year-old New York councils' move presents an unusually acute departure from the national policy. Wahls said it was the first case he was aware of that a council publicly acknowledged that one of its adult staffers was gay.

The New York councils serve more than 46,000 young people, in both boys' scout troops and other programs, such as pre-professional "explorer" initiatives; some include girls. About 9,000 boys and girls are expected in its summer camps this year.

Tessier achieved scouting's highest rank last year after being one of the most prominent openly gay scouts speaking out to change the ban on gay participation.

The Kensington, Maryland, teen said then he was relieved finally to have his Eagle badge approved by the Scouts' national headquarters in Irving, Texas.

"Even if I had been kicked out along the way, I wouldn't have changed anything," he said. "The whole experience was something worth having, not only for myself but also for all the other people involved - and for all the people it affects."


(Some information from the Associated Press.)