Suffolk County police Inspector Kevin Kane said the initial minor crash happened just after noon at the corner of Montauk Highway and Venetian Promenade in Lindenhurst.
One of the involved vehicles, a 2016 Subaru operated by an 85-year-old man, then backed into the eastbound lane of Montauk Highway, where it struck a third car, a 2004 Mercury Marquee, operated by 78-year-old Joseph Abitabile with his 76-year-old wife Delores as a passenger.
Also Read: Chick-fil-A worker rescues child choking in drive-thru lane
As the result of the secondary collision, the Mercury was propelled through a fence and into the canal.
The Suffolk County Police Department released the following video of the crash and rescue:
Within seconds, several good Samaritans -- including off-duty Suffolk police Officer John Tighe -- jumped into the water. At that time, the car was only partially submerged
"When I see the guy underwater, I say, 'This is my father or somebody's father,'" said good Samaritan Mustafa Tosun, who works at a gas station across the street. "I had to do something. I didn't care."
Suffolk police responded, and on-duty Officer Debra Gearon also jumped into the water.
Joseph Abitable was able to get out of the car with assistance from good Samaritans before the car was fully submerged, but Delores Abitable was unable to get out before the vehicle was fully underwater.
Those in the water attempted to break the glass of the car using a cinderblock, before Gearon was able to to break the back windshield with a spring-loaded center punch.
Also Read: California mother missing for 12 days in Zion National Park found safe
She was pulled from the car with no pulse, but Lake Success Officer Robert Russo performed CPR and was able to restore her pulse and breathing.
The Abitabiles, of Massapequa; one good Samaritan; the two Suffolk County police officers; and the driver of the Subaru, 65-year-old Morris Kramer, of Atlantic Beach, were transported to Good Samaritan Hospital Medical Center in West Islip for treatment of non-life-threatening injuries.
The driver of the third vehicle, Greg Destefano, was not injured.
* More Long Island news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts
* Follow us on YouTube
Submit a News Tip