John and Mary Quick are charged with endangering the welfare of a vulnerable adult and grand larceny.
On Tuesday night, all was quiet at Silent Farms, the horse farm and bed and breakfast in the rolling hills of Goshen.
Where in a scheme out of a Dickens novel, state police say the owners, John and Mary Quick, took advantage of a now 61-year-old mentally disabled farmhand, having him work for them for free for years.
"If I had to guess, this started off with a certain amount of wellbeing and deteriorated over time. That's as best we can tell," police said.
State police investigators spent three months piecing it together. Over more than a decade, they say, the grown man lived in a converted apartment in a barn on the property, and tended to the land and the horses.
But then a neighbor discovered he in fact had no heat or running water and called the police.
The police determined the Quicks were also accessing his bank account and getting their hands on his Social Security benefits.
From behind "no trespassing" signs Tuesday night, the Quicks refused to address the allegations.
"They don't treat people like that. They treat dogs better than that," said Brian, a family friend. "If you know this family that would never happen."
"Okay. So was there heat and running water?" Eyewitness News Reporter Josh Einiger asked.
"Of course there was. It was a full apartment there for him, I don't know where that story came from," Brian said. "From what I heard from one of the tenants here, he had about five bags of groceries before Social Services showed up and he gave away all the food before they got here. So when they came he said, 'Look, I have no food.'"
John Quick was arraigned in the Village of Florida Court and remanded to Orange County Jail in lieu of $500 bail or $1000 bond and ordered to appear in the Town of Goshen Court Wednesday afternoon.
Mary Quick was arraigned in the Village of Court and released on her own recognizance and ordered to reappear in the Town of Goshen Court at the same time as her husband.