The boys were trapped on the lake at Edith Read Sanctuary in Rye when they called for help.
"We were just there on the island...and then we saw the cop - two guys come out with a little trailer, and pulled us in," says Gian Dellicolli. "That's really all they did for us. Then they gave us a good old lecture."
The ice held up to the weight of the rescuers and the teens safely were able to make it off without any injuries.