Drury spotted the ring at the Twin Oaks Ice Rink in Morristown in February.
Merrill Hess didn't realize that's where he had lost the ring.
The 82-year-old was assistant scouting director for the Pirates in 1960.
Hess found Drury's posting on Google that she had found a ring belonging to "Merrill Mess."
Hess gave the girl a check, a gift certificate and an autographed photograph from the 1960 series.