Cotto is a pastor at the Congregation Yahweh at 20 Chester Avenue. He also is affiliated with Yahweh Congregations in Jersey City and Paterson. Pabon is a member of the congregation in Newark. The two began having an affair in 2008 and would meet regularly at the Benedict Motel in Linden where the alleged abuse took place.
It's not clear when the girls first encountered the couple, but the meetings at the motel reportedly continued until about two weeks ago when one of the girls told a parent about the abuse. .
Cotto was arrested at his home on Monday. Pabon surrendered to authorities on Tuesday. Both are being held on bail. Cotto is charged with kidnapping, attempted aggravated assault, aggravated sexual assault and endangering the welfare of a minor. Pabon also is charged with kidnapping and endangering the welfare of a minor.