Each time, the suspect pointed a gun at the victim and demanded their purse or wallet -- and now many are asking for more police patrols in the park.
On Thursday, a sharp-eyed police officer spotted the suspect's bike from a grainy surveillance photo and found the man it belonged -- 34-year-old Andrew Thornton. Police also found Thornton's loaded gun
The most recent incident happened Tuesday afternoon when police say Thornton confronted a 67-year-old woman near Swan Lake.
He took out a gun and said to the woman, "I need to take your purse."
The woman asked him if she could keep her cell phone and he refused. Fearing for her safety, the victim handed over her purse that had two credit cards, an iPhone 10, eye medication and approximately $200 in cash.
The victim's phone was later recovered by police near the scene using the "Find My iPhone" feature.
In the other instance last week, on April 30 around 8:25 a.m., police say Thornton tried to sell his bike to a man for $75.
When the man declined, he asked him for $5, which he also declined and walked away.
The victim then sat down on a bench near the 72nd Street and 5th Avenue exit, when he noticed the man was standing in front of him.
Police say Thornton then took out a semi-automatic pistol and demanded money. Fearing for his life, the victim complied and gave him $1,000 in cash.
Other than being shaken up, the victims were not harmed.
The attacks have parkgoers nervous. According to the latest NYPD crime statistics, robberies in the city are up nearly 30 percent over this same time last year.
"For years Central Park has been very safe, I'm very concerned it's like New York in the '70s," one parkgoer said.
NYPD' Central Park's commanding officer Bill Gallagher had called in extra resources to flood the park in search for Thornton -- they ordered up a sketch of him, and released a surveillance picture. It all paid off Thursday morning, when they took Thornton into custody after they found him sleeping in a tent near Strawberry Fields.
ALSO READ | Woman, 94, loses tax exemptions when she is assumed dead
* Get Eyewitness News Delivered
* More Manhattan news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts
* Follow us on YouTube