Man who "orchestrated" hit on mob associate sentenced to prison

Dan Krauth Image
Thursday, June 8, 2023
Man who orchestrated hit on mob associate sentenced to prison
A judge ordered Bushawn Shelton to prison for 37 years. He pled guilty to conspiracy to commit murder for hire.

NEW YORK (WABC) -- It sounds like a story out of a mob movie, but it's not, its real life.

71-year-old mob associate Sylvester Zottola survived six assassination attempts over a one-year period, only to get gunned down and murdered doing something he did often - order a cup of coffee at a McDonald's drive-thru in the Bronx.

"It was a hit, there's no doubt about it," said retired NYPD Chief of Detectives Robert Boyce. "It's a unique case in the fact that it overtly looks like a mob related case and it wasn't."

During all of those assassination attempts, Zottola had no idea his own son Anthony was behind the attacks on his life.

On Thursday in Federal Court, the man prosecutors said Anthony hired to orchestrate the murder was sentenced. A judge ordered Bushawn Shelton to prison for 37 years. He plead guilty to conspiracy to commit murder for hire.

In court, Shelton had an opportunity to speak directly to the Zottola family and said "I'm sorry, I'm truly sorry" and "I've been waiting for years to express my regret and my remorse to you."

Prosecutors said Anthony hired Shelton, a Bloods gang member with a desk job, who then hired other gang members to drive the getaway car and pull the trigger.

In April, Anthony Zottola was sentenced to life behind bars without the possibility of parole. After a six week jury trial, he was convicted of hiring gang members to kill his father to get the family fortune.

The hitman hired to fire the fatal shots, Himen Ross, was also sentenced to life in prison.

"For more than a year, the defendant led the charge in stalking, beating, stabbing, and eventually shooting an elderly man purely for money," state United States Attorney Breon Peace.

Detectives said Sylvester, known as Sally Daz, made a fortune off joker poker machines and invested that money into a multimillion dollar real estate portfolio.

"It's a lot of money for a street guy," said Boyce.

"He was good friend with Vincent Basciano," said Boyce. "Sylvester was an associate, he wasn't made."

Back in September of 2017, someone punched and knocked Sylvester Zottola to the ground outside his home, it was captured on home surveillance video.

Then in November of 2017, police records show he was "menaced at gunpoint by a masked individual," while driving down the Throgs Neck Expressway.

On December 27th of 2017, three men broken into his home and slashed his throat. He survived.

"We didn't think he was going to make it," said Boyce. "He was in the ICU for a while, it was a question whether he was going to pull through and as history shows, he did pull through."

After recovering from the slashing, in June of 2018 a hooded man held a pistol to Zottola's head outside his home, but the gun misfired. Zottola got out his own gun and fired back. It's captured on home surveillance camera.

A month later, someone tried to kill his son Salvatore. A gunman walked up to him outside his home and opened fired just a few feet away. Salvatore was hit, but rolled down the street when the shots were fired which ultimately helped save his life. The incident was also captured on surveillance cameras. He was hospitalized but survived.

On October 4th of that year, Sylvester was shot multiple times while in the drive-thru of McDonald's.

A McDonald's employee working the drive-thru window witnessed what happened and called 911. She told the dispatcher "We're just taking care of customers, somebody just ran to the car and shot at him."

"It was an old-fashioned hit, right out of a mobster movie," said Boyce.

Police later found a tracking device on Zottola's car. The hitmen had been tracking his movements.

They also obtained text messages that showed Anthony plotted the murder with gang member Bushawn Shelton.

Anthony was one of 10 people charged in the death of his father. When police arrested him, he told detectives, "I had a feel you were coming. When I don't know but I can thank you that it was after Father's Day and it was after all my kids' birthdays."


DO YOU NEED A STORY INVESTIGATED? Dan Krauth and the 7 On Your Side Investigates team at Eyewitness News want to hear from you! Call our confidential tip line 1-877-TIP-NEWS (847-6397) or fill out the form BELOW. You can also contact Dan Krauth directly:

Email your questions, issues, or story ideas to

Facebook: DanKrauthReports

Twitter: @ DanKrauthABC7

Instagram: @DanKrauth