Challenge to Jewish religious chicken-killing ritual defeated in court

Wednesday, November 14, 2018
EMBED <>More Videos

The New York Court of Appeals delivered a big victory to the ultra-orthodox Jewish community which has been defending an ancient atonement tradition known as Kaporos.

NEW YORK (WABC) -- The New York Court of Appeals delivered a big victory Wednesday to the ultra-orthodox Jewish community which has been defending an ancient atonement tradition known as Kaporos.

The ritual involves waving a chicken over one's head three times while reciting a prayer for forgiveness then slitting the chicken's throat.

Each year, the ritual results in thousands of chickens being slaughtered throughout New York City ahead of Yom Kippur.

Animal rights groups have argued the ritual violates more than a dozen New York health and safety and animal cruelty laws which the city chooses not to enforce.

In 2015, the group, Alliance to end Chickens for Kaporos, sued the New York City Police Department hoping a judge would require the department to enforce those laws.

However, a New York Appellate Court ruled that the department could use discretion in enforcing those health, safety and animal cruelty laws as it related to this religious ritual.

Wednesday, the state's Appeals Court released an opinion affirming that ruling, meaning Kaporos will be able to continue without change.

"It's disturbing that the city continues to turn a blind eye to 15 laws being violated," said Nora Constance Marino, the attorney representing the Alliance to end Chickens for Kaporos. "We are disappointed that the court did not exercise their judicial power to right this wrong and we continue to explore other legal remedies."

Members of the ultra-orthodox community said they were delighted by the victory.

"We knew the law was on our side," said Rabbi Shea Hecht, Chairman of the National Committee for the Furtherance of Jewish Education. "Today's opinion is a victory not only for our community but also a victory for New Yorkers and religious freedom as a whole."

Hecht said he hopes that with the court's decision both sides can agree to disagree and move on peacefully, but added he expects new legal challenges from opponents will follow.

DO YOU NEED A STORY INVESTIGATED?

Jim Hoffer, Danielle Leigh and the 7 On Your Side Investigates team at Eyewitness News want to hear from you! Call our confidential tip line 1-877-TIP-NEWS (847-6397) or fill out the form BELOW.

You can also contact Jim and Danielle directly:

Jim Hoffer:

Email your questions, issues, or story ideas to 7OnYourSideJim@abc.com

Facebook: facebook.com/jimhoffer.wabc

Twitter: @NYCinvestigates

Danielle Leigh

Email your questions, issues, or story ideas to 7OnYourSideDanielle@abc.com

Facebook: DanielleLeighJournalist

Twttier: @DanielleNLeigh

If using the app, click here to send us a news tip

----------

* More New York City news

* Send us a news tip

* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts

* Follow us on YouTube



If using the app, click here to send us a news tip

----------
* More New York City news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts
* Follow us on YouTube","dateline":"NEW YORK (WABC) --","meta":{"description":"The New York Court of Appeals delivered a big victory Wednesday to the ultra-orthodox Jewish community which has been defending an ancient atonement tradition known as Kaporos."},"owner":{"source":"WABC","authors":[],"origin":"WABC","logo":"https://cdn.abcotvs.net/abcotv/assets/news/wabc/images/logos/origin.png"},"reportTypo":true,"segments":{"locationSegments":[],"topicSegments":[{"id":2227522,"shortTextID":"lifetravel","displayName":"Life, Food & Travel"}]},"syndication":true,"search":true,"featuredMediaType":"video","inlineJsNeeded":{"chimney":false,"scrbbl":false,"vine":false}},"allowAmp":true},"ads":{"network":21783347309,"base":"kabc","kvps":[{"name":"aff","value":"wabc"},{"name":"chan","value":"wabc"},{"name":"lang","value":"en"},{"name":"pgn"},{"name":"pgtyp","value":"post"},{"name":"objid","value":"4689682"},{"name":"tag","value":"7-on-your-side-investigation,animals,jewish,chicken"},{"name":"tags","value":"7-on-your-side-investigation,animals,jewish,chicken"}],"selector":".ad-slot","sizes":{"leaderboard1":{"defaultSize":[728,90],"mappings":[{"viewport":[1030,0],"slot":[[970,90],[728,90]]},{"viewport":[748,0],"slot":[728,90]},{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[320,50]}]},"leaderboard2":{"defaultSize":[728,90],"mappings":[{"viewport":[1030,0],"slot":[[970,90],[728,90]]},{"viewport":[748,0],"slot":[728,90]},{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[320,50]}]},"sponsoredByLogo":{"defaultSize":[88,31],"mappings":[{"viewport":[748,0],"slot":[320,51]},{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[88,31]}]},"sponsoredByLogoEvent":{"defaultSize":[88,32],"mappings":[{"viewport":[748,0],"slot":[320,52]},{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[88,32]}]},"sponsoredByLogoModule":{"defaultSize":[88,33],"mappings":[{"viewport":[748,0],"slot":[320,53]},{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[88,33]}]},"rectangle":{"defaultSize":[300,250],"mappings":[{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[300,250]}]},"halfpage":{"defaultSize":[300,250],"mappings":[{"viewport":[748,0],"slot":[[300,600],[300,250]]},{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[300,250]}]},"incontent1":{"defaultSize":[300,250],"mappings":[{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[300,250]}]},"incontent2":{"defaultSize":[300,250],"mappings":[{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[300,250]}]},"incontent3":{"defaultSize":[300,250],"mappings":[{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[300,250]}]},"native":{"defaultSize":[1,1],"mappings":[{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[1,1]}]},"interstitial":{"defaultSize":[1,1],"mappings":[{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[1,1]}]},"fitt-article-right-rail":{"defaultSize":[[300,250],[300,600]],"mappings":[{"viewport":[1024,0],"slot":[[300,250],[300,600]]},{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[]}]},"fitt-article-top-banner":{"defaultSize":[[970,250],[970,66],[728,90]],"mappings":[{"viewport":[1024,0],"slot":[[970,250],[970,66],[728,90]]},{"viewport":[768,0],"slot":[[728,90]]},{"viewport":[300,0],"slot":[[320,50]]},{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[]}]},"fitt-article-inline-outstream":{"defaultSize":[[1,3],[300,250]],"mappings":[{"viewport":[1280,0],"slot":[[1,3],[300,250]]},{"viewport":[1024,0],"slot":[[1,3],[300,250]]},{"viewport":[768,0],"slot":[[1,3],[300,250]]},{"viewport":[300,0],"slot":[[1,3],[300,250]]}]},"fitt-article-inline-box":{"defaultSize":[[300,250]],"mappings":[{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[[300,250]]}]},"prestitial":{"defaultSize":[1,1],"mappings":[{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[1,1]}]},"overpage":{"defaultSize":[1,1],"mappings":[{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[1,1]}]},"adhesion":{"defaultSize":[728,90],"mappings":[{"viewport":[1030,0],"slot":[[970,90],[728,90]]},{"viewport":[748,0],"slot":[[728,90]]},{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[320,50]}]},"follow_ad":{"defaultSize":[2,2],"mappings":[{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[2,2]}]},"folding_ad":{"defaultSize":[2,2],"mappings":[{"viewport":[0,0],"slot":[2,2]}]}},"breakpoints":{"l":[1030],"m":[748,1029],"s":[0,747]},"supportDynamicPageLoad":true,"delayInPageAdSlots":true,"disableInitialLoad":true,"refreshOnBreakpointChange":true,"dynamicKeyValues":{"profile":{"key":"prof"}},"id":12129264,"disabled":"false","incontentPositions":{"defaults":{"favorites":-1,"now":4,"news":4},"index":{"top":{"favorites":-1},"nfl":{}}},"load":{"defaults":{"desktop":"init","mobile":"window.load","tablet":"init"},"frontpage":{"desktop":"init","mobile":"window.load","tablet":"init"},"story":{"desktop":"window.load","mobile":"window.load","tablet":"window.load"},"index":{"desktop":"window.load","mobile":"window.load","tablet":"window.load"},"scoreboard":{"desktop":"window.load","mobile":"window.load","tablet":"window.load"},"standings":{"desktop":"window.load","mobile":"window.load","tablet":"window.load"},"schedule":{"desktop":"window.load","mobile":"window.load","tablet":"window.load"}},"preBidConfig":{"usePreBid":true},"level":"wabc/abc7ny.com/web/religion"},"analytics":{"accountID":"wdgotvwabcresponsive","ns":"abcotv","pageName":"religion/post_video/challenge-to-jewish-religious-chicken-killing-ritual-defeated-in-court=4689682","station":"wabc","stationName":"ABC7 New York","pageType":"prism-story","liveTitle":"ABC7 New York 24/7 Eyewitness News Stream","dateModified":1542238557,"canonical":"https://abc7ny.com/religion/challenge-to-jewish-religious-chicken-killing-ritual-defeated-in-court/4689682/","id":4689682,"section":{"name":"wabc","path":"wabc","root":"abc7ny.com"},"title":"Challenge to Jewish religious chicken-killing ritual defeated in court","type":"post","link":"https://abc7ny.com/religion/challenge-to-jewish-religious-chicken-killing-ritual-defeated-in-court/4689682/","owner":{"source":"WABC","authors":[],"origin":"WABC","logo":"https://cdn.abcotvs.net/abcotv/assets/news/wabc/images/logos/origin.png"},"source":"WABC","taxonomy":{"tags":["7-on-your-side-investigation","animals","jewish","chicken"],"places":["new-york-city"],"topic":"religion","hicCategory":"None"},"featuredData":{"video":[]},"fmDataType":"video","fmViewType":"hidden"}},"request":{"headers":{},"httpVersion":"1.1","method":"GET","url":"/religion/challenge-to-jewish-religious-chicken-killing-ritual-defeated-in-court/4689682/","vary":{"host":"abc7ny.com","cached":true,"path":"/religion/challenge-to-jewish-religious-chicken-killing-ritual-defeated-in-court/4689682/","forwarded-proto":"https","device":"desktop"}},"viewport":{"width":1260,"height":0,"scrollX":0,"scrollY":0},"user":{}};