Prosecutors say 60-year-old Thomas Murphy was drunk when he slammed into a group of Boy Scouts last year in Manorville, killing Andrew McMorris.
Murphy faces vehicular homicide and other charges and was apparently offered an unspecified plea agreement, which he rejected in court Thursday. Previously, he had told the judge he needed more time to consider it.
"I ask respectfully that those who come to court, allow myself and my family the time to fully evaluate my case, and my role in this tragic accident," Stephen McCarthy, Murphy's defense attorney, read in court last month.
Judge Fernando Camacho told Murphy he was running out of patience, called the move a delay tactic, and told him there wouldn't be much time.
Dozens of supporters of the victim, including family and friends, packed the courthouse and walked in holding photos of the victim. They said they were disheartened by Murphy's decision after what has been a long and painful road.
"He'll never have a chance to grow up, he'll never have a chance to graduate high school, college, he'll never have a chance to be the pilot he always dreamed about being, never have a family of his own," dad John McMorris said. "And we're going to fight for Andrew."
Prosecutors say Murphy's blood alcohol content was more than twice the legal limit when he allegedly turned down a ride after drinking and playing golf and drove off in his BMW.
He then rammed into a group of Boy Scouts, authorities say, injuring four and killing McMorris.
Andrew's parents are resolved to see justice, even if it takes longer than they expect.
"You know, when all this is over, I still don't get my baby back, and he gets to go home," mom Alisa McMorris said. "Even after he serves his time, he gets to go home to his family. My baby doesn't."
A pre-trial hearing is set for June. If convicted, Murphy faces up to 25 years behind bars.
* More Long Island news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts
* Follow us on YouTube