Officials believe someone got into the basement of The Theater Center and stole the copper pipes the night of January 20.
No pipes means no water, no heat and no shows.
"It's kind of ironic we're closed not due to COVID, but due to another perfect crime which is the title of the play," said the General Manager of the Theater Center Catherine Russell.
Russell is also the lead actress in the show and said another suspect tried to kick in the theater's front door Sunday night.
"Boy, that was one angry man," said Russell. "He was kicking with these big boots. Kicking, kicking, kicking, the glass door. Pretty violent"
The theater is also home to "The Office: A Musical Parody" which was also shuttered while repairs were being made.
ALSO READ | Mayor Adams unveils New York City's 'Blueprint for Safety' to combat violence
The lock of an empty pub space was broken, which may have been the thieves point of entry.
Monday night plywood covered the vulnerable entrance.
As life imitates art, for these unfortunately actors, Eyewitness News was told it cost more than $20,000 to replace the pipes.
That's not including all the loss in ticket sales for both shows.
The copper pieces that were stolen might only make the thieves a measly few hundred dollars. So far no arrests have been made.
Russell has never been sick or taken a vacation from the theater in 34 years, and she says can't wait to get back in character.
"'Perfect Crime' was the first show to open after COVID," Russell said.
The pipes have now been replaced. The heat is back on and the building is warming up. The show will go on, starting Thursday.
* Get Eyewitness News Delivered
* More New York City news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts
* Follow us on YouTube
Submit a News Tip