Julie Angelicola visited the NJ Transit Customer Service Center at Penn Station to retrieve the ring, which she believed had been flushed down a train toilet while she was washing her hands.
The watch was given to Roosevelt by his sister in 1898 and was stolen in July 1987 from the the Wilcox House in Buffalo.
This week's MTA Hero reunited a scared, lost boy with his mother and his "Grammy".
A teenager from Minnesota loves to fish, and the 14-year-old made a big catch recently.
A volunteer diver helped reunite a woman with her lost wedding ring after he found it at the bottom of a California lake over the weekend.
The item was lost during the 'Top Gun: Maverick' premiere last year and presumed to be gone forever until it turned up on a subway.